Monday, September 12, 2011

And Mercy, More Than Life

September 11, 2011
Matthew 18:21-35

How many times must I forgive a brother or sister? Peter asked Jesus. As many as seven times? That’s a lot. No, Jesus said, not seven times, and you can almost hear Peter begin to say “Whew.” Not seven times but seventy seven times, or seven times 70 times, or a bazillion times. Why? Because God’s forgiveness knows no limit. We forgive, because God has forgiven us.
Because, Jesus said, God is like this—and then he told a story. He told a story because people remember stories. We carry stories around inside ourselves. Sometimes we might forget a story until some clue calls it to mind, and we think to ourselves, gee, I haven’t thought of that story for years. But there it is. Like a lot of rabbis and prophets before him Jesus taught in stories. And here’s the story.
A king, or maybe we could say a banker, decided to call in his loans. One of his debtors owed him 10,000 talents, which in modern currency would be like you or I owing the bank a bazillion dollars. 10,000 talents is like 30 lifetimes of income-- an impossible amount. The debtor begged his creditor, have patience with me and I’ll pay you back every cent. This was a desperate lie. There was no way that he could pay the debt, unless he lived for about 2000 years.
In the prophetic tradition of parable-preaching, the king is and isn’t God—that’s the way it is with parables, it’s not a strict allegory. So the king is—and isn’t-- God, the servant is—and isn’t-- Israel, or we could say the church or the nation or all of us together. Everything we are, we owe to God. We could not possibly begin to repay God for the gift of life, for the earth our home, for the land and sky and sea and all the riches that we put to use as if they were our own. If God were to require payment, we would be in deep trouble. We could whine, plead, and try to make some desperate kind of deal, but really, we could never, ever pay for all that God has given us.
Fortunately, God doesn’t demand payment. Life is a gift. We are all benefactors of a generous God, a benevolent ruler, a merciful judge.
In the parable, after having been forgiven of this enormous, impossible, unpayable debt, after being saved from slavery along with his wife and children, the debtor, we’ll call him debtor #1, runs into a guy, we’ll call him debtor #2,  who owes him some money-- a lot of money, but not a ridiculous amount. 100 denari=100 days pay, so whatever 100 days pay is for you, we’ll say he owed that much. Debtor #2 begs for mercy, promises to pay the debt, which he could do. But the one who was shown mercy does not emulate his former creditor. Debtor #1 seems to forget immediately the mercy that he received, his brain is like a sieve, the memory of desperation and mercy and relief was there and then gone. Rather than forgive as he was forgiven, the unforgiving servant has debtor #2 thrown into prison.
I believe this is where Jesus ended the parable. But the author of the Gospel of Matthew seems to have been uneasy with open endings, and was always adding material, expanding and explaining parables. What’s the point of telling a parable if you’re going to explain it? But the author is a literary artist. Matthew’s conclusion to this passage puts a beautiful literary parentheses around the parable, frames the parable with these two phrases about forgiveness: Peter’s question “If a brother or sister sins against me” opens the parentheses and “if you do not forgive a brother or sister” closes it. Thus the parable is framed by our relationship to each other, as brothers and sisters, and by sin and forgiveness.
Every Sunday we pray “forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.” As if God’s forgiveness was conditioned upon our forgiving others. But according to the parable, it’s actually the other way around. God forgives us first. God has forgiven us our debt. We couldn’t begin to pay it anyway, but the least we can do in response to God’s mercy is to show mercy to others.
The quality of God’s mercy is not strained, as Portia testified in The Merchant of Venice. It pours down from heaven as the gentle rain. It is twice blessed, it blesses the one who gives as well as the one who receives. On earth as it is in heaven, earthly power is most like God’s “when mercy seasons justice.” When mercy seasons justice. I love that phrase.
As I remember 9/11/2001, the worst terrorist attack in the United States immediately inspired grace and mercy. I remember how strangers—even in New York, of all places (I like a lot of Midwesterners, had the idea that New York City is the last place on earth to look for kindness)-- helped each other find their way to safety. I remember that as some people ran from the cloud of dust as the towers fell, others ran toward it. I remember the generous expressions of sympathy from people all over the world.
But, I also remember how, in the days after 9/11, the cry for justice became a call to vengeance, and I remember how, as a nation, we disagreed over the measures of mercy and justice. We still disagree to this day, I know. Ten years later we still argue how things might have been different if only, if only…. Until we learn to forgive as we have been forgiven, to give as we have received from God, to show mercy as we have seen mercy, until then we live in a kind of hell of our own making. We torture ourselves.
On this tenth anniversary, I remember, and I hope that we can move into the future as better people, as people who have learned from the past and are ready to repent, as people who are ready to excel in showing mercy.
It is from the third verse of the hymn “America the Beautiful” that I take the title for this sermon, and it is my sincere hope that we may prove heroic in loving, and generous with mercy.
“O Beautiful, for heroes proved in liberating strife, who more than self their county loved, and mercy, more than life. America, America, may God thy gold refine, ‘til all success be nobleness and every gain, divine.” May it be so. Amen.

Friday, September 9, 2011

Pulling Up Stakes

28 August 2011
Matthew 16:21-28

"If any want to become my followers, let them deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me. For those who want to save their life will lose it, and those who lose their life for my sake will find it.”

                Anyone who has attempted to make themselves understood in a second, acquired language knows the difficulty, and the importance of culture and context in making oneself understood. How many American exchange students in Germany have blundered, in an effort to communicate to their host family that their room is too warm, said: “I am hot—Ich bin heiss,” only to later realize that what they actually said was “I am enflamed with passion.” That would explain the Teutonic laughter.
                When we read scripture what we are actually reading is a translation of a transcript, which was itself translated and transmitted orally, so it is always possible that we have lost something in translation.
                “If any want to become my followers, let them deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me.” The idea of “taking up the cross,” and the phrase “my cross to bear,” have become commonplace in our language. So much so that we hardly give the phrase a thought. We think we know what it means: to endure something unpleasant, because God apparently requires suffering.
                As in, yes, my husband beats me, but that’s just my cross to bear.”
                Yes, I have an addiction, but that’s just my cross to bear.”
                As if there is something singularly redemptive in enduring suffering, and something selfish and sinful in standing up and casting it off.
                Well, I think that’s just messed up.

                The actual Greek phrase could mean take up your cross, and considering the death that Jesus died, in hindsight that translation seemed to make sense. But literally, it says “take up your stick,” or “pull up your stake” as in, “strike camp.” Pull up stakes, get ready to go, don’t get comfortable here. Get moving!
                Considering Israel’s history as a migrant people, following flocks and herds across the land, and considering that Jesus frequently used pastoral images, this interpretation seems just as likely as the traditional. And, even more so, considering how the Hebrew Scriptures emphasize the preservation of life. God moves to preserve life. When Joseph was reunited with his brothers in Egypt, he reflected how God was at work in his story, to preserve not only his life, but his brother’s lives, to save their lives and preserve their future. Throughout the arc of scripture, God intervenes to save life. But often saving life requires letting go of everything else, even, in Joseph’s case, freedom.
                I think “taking up your cross,” or pulling up stakes, is more about preserving life than losing it. Or rather, more about preserving life that is real life, casting off a half-life or a living death. It’s about being ready to give up certitude for truth, and comfortable slavery for untested freedom.
                What it looks like, in practice, is cutting the ties that bind us to abusive relationships, and stepping up and out into a new life. Abuse is no one’s cross to bear.
                What it might look like, in practice, for the one who suffers from addiction is confronting that addiction, which is not an essential part of who you are, but a demon to be vanquished or a parasite to be purged from your system. Addiction is no one’s cross to bear.
                What “pulling up stakes” looks like for each of us, we have to work out for ourselves, by asking, “What is it that holds me down? What is it that holds me back from life that is really life?” Ask not “What am I willing to die for,” but ask “What am I willing to live for until I die?”
                So let us contemplate what the Spirit is telling the church, about how to live. Amen.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Jesus Has a Problem with Authority

Text: Matthew 15:1-28
14 August 2011

I am not an angry girl
but it seems like I've got everyone fooled
every time I say something they find hard to hear
they chalk it up to my anger
and never to their own fear
                    --Ani Difranco, from “Not a Pretty Girl”

                When I first heard Ani Difranco sing these lyrics, about ten years ago I guess, I thought she had summed up my entire academic and professional career. Because, the men who taught feminist theology honored women with their speeches and lectures, but, rarely did the radical reassessment of culture actually cause a change in the institutions of the seminary or the church.
                For example, when I went to Eden Seminary, the ladies’ room still had urinals. Because there didn’t used to be a ladies’ room, it was a seminary, a school for men; and though there had been a steady stream of women students since at least the 1950’s, it apparently never occurred to anyone to adjust the restroom fixtures accordingly. Someone did, however, put some plastic ferns in the ladies’ room urinals to disguise them, but it was not a very good disguise. When we complained, the administration responded with, “What’s the big deal? Why are you so angry?”
                We weren’t angry. We were just doing what they taught us to do. We were applying a feminist hermeneutic of suspicion to the institution. We were pointing out the disconnect between what the institution said, “We welcome all students,” and what they did, or failed to do, which gave a distinctly different message, that message being “but in case this doesn’t work out we’ll still be able to use this as a men’s room.” Every day, every time we walked into the ladies’ toilet, we were reminded, “You really don’t belong here.”
                And since that time whenever I’ve pointed out the dissonance between mission and action, the response is always something sounding of irritation masked as concern: “Do you have a problem with authority?” I remember when the Iowa Conference, after declaring a conference-wide priority to encourage young families to be more involved at the conference level, then announced that they would no longer provide childcare at the annual meeting because it was not profitable. More recently, we read that our Conference Board of Directors imagines that in the future we will “grow younger” as a conference. This is the same Board that announced the plan to close our church camp, a significant place for ministry to children, youth and families. Remember how hard we had to work to make our voices heard? And remember how the board of directors responded with a patronizing attitude, saying something to the effect of, “If you only understood what we understand about our Conference finances you would make the same decision.” This is another way of saying, “Do you have a problem with authority? Don’t you trust the process?”
                No. I don’t trust the process. And yes, I have a problem with authority, like my Lord Jesus.         
                When Jesus criticized the Pharisees, they probably thought something like this: “Well he would say that being as he’s from Galilee. It’s a reflection on his class and his race (he’s practically a Samaritan!); it’s not a reflection on us. He’s got a problem with authority. Probably relates to some childhood or adolescent trauma.”
                “Every time I say something they find hard to hear, they chalk it up to my anger, and never to their own fear.”
                Interesting thing about this gospel lesson, even though Jesus could recognize hypocrisy in others, he couldn’t see it in himself, not right away, anyway. He criticized the Pharisees with one breath and in the next he cursed a woman who came to him for help, calling her a dog, and calling her child a dog. But she stood up for herself and she challenged him, and taught Jesus a lesson.
Thank God Jesus didn’t turn on her and say, “Girl, you have a problem with authority. Get back where you belong!”
                Jesus realized truth when he heard it. Jesus was not too full of himself to learn something from that woman, something about the righteous use of his own authority. Not to Lord it over her, but to serve and to heal. And that is what he taught his disciples, that the greatest of all must be the servant of all. Wonder where he learned that.
                So here is the challenge: Not just to apply the hermeneutic of suspicion to those we perceive as being above us, but to listen to those we think below us, and to apply the hermeneutic of suspicion to ourselves. When somebody says something we find hard to hear, why do we chalk it up to their anger, and never our own fear?
                I just returned from the Pine Ridge reservation, with the faith formation class. All week, we heard things that were hard to hear; things they never told us in high school history class. Not only about the massacre at Wounded Knee, not only about the small pox blankets and the decimation of the buffalo herds and the forced relocation and short rations. We also learned a lot about the consequences of doing what we think is right, without asking the people for whom we are ostensibly doing it-- the missions, the boarding schools, the housing clusters, the FEMA trailers. It seems like every time we try to intervene for good, we do bad, because we don’t know what we’re doing and we don’t bother to ask the people.
                 I hope we are beginning to learn from our mistakes. I hope we are beginning to have a problem with our own authority. I hope we are learning to listen to those who we thought had nothing to teach us.
We just returned from Pine Ridge. I believe we caught a glimpse of a new world, while we were there, working side by side with Lakota people. I hope we can share some idea of what the next world might look like, if we learn to listen to each other. Watch this.

Monday, July 25, 2011

God’s Place

24 July 2011
Matthew 13:31-33, 44-52

The kingdom of heaven as if someone should blow on a dandelion flower. A single seed floats on the breeze and takes root in the corner of the garden, and before you know it the whole lawn is covered in a Roundup resistant variety.
The kingdom of heaven is like Eurasian milfoil. By the time you notice it, the plant has taken over the lake. And the more you cut it, the more it grows.
The kingdom of heaven is like a zebra mussel….
When Jesus told these parables, the listeners knew that Jesus was comparing God’s kingdom to things which were noxious weeds, invasive species, and ritually unclean. We don’t really have a “ritually unclean” equivalent in modern society, but I think the hated zebra mussel comes the closest. Poor zebra mussel. It never meant to take over our lakes. It’s not as if some terrorist zebra mussel organization—the ZMLO-- planned an invasion…. A mussel’s got to do what a mussel’s got to do… whatever that is.
Same with milfoil and dandelions. It is in their nature to grow, to resist attack, to persist in growing and spreading abroad. Floating on the air, drifting through the water, as innocent as it is unstoppable.
Jesus was speaking to a people who were as weeds to the empire. Families, whole villages, were plucked up from their land forced to move elsewhere, or be crushed. Their ancestral lands were given to those who were deemed more appropriate: Roman settlers, soldiers and officers, the Vichy government or whatever its equivalent was—those who collaborated in their own country’s colonization.
So when they heard Jesus evoking the kingdom of God, not in the Holy temple or the ritually consecrated furnishings associated with it, but in the common, the base, the untouchable, the ritually unclean…. They knew he was talking about them.
The kingdom of God is not like the priests; the kingdom of God is not like the legions, the kingdom of God is like you. The presence of God is among you, the despised, the forgotten, the plucked up and the crushed. But like the yeast you rise. Like the weeds, you grow tall and strong. God is at work in you.
It was a scandalous joy! The way Jesus talked, it was a scandalous joy! Here is a rabbi talking about God among us. Scandalous! Joy!
Do you understand? Jesus asked. “Ye-es” the disciples said, but did they really? And do we? The church began as an underground movement. Small, poor, despised, afflicted, but growing, in spite of persecutions, it continued to grow. Because Christians saw the presence of God in the despised of the earth, and they reached out and cared for those who had no one else to care for them.
But as the church grew, and received the patronage of the empire that crucified Jesus, it began to emulate the empire, rather than God’s kingdom.
So we must tell each other these stories again and again, to remind ourselves of God’s place in the world. God is found in the last place we would look.
 As a church, we do a lot of good things. We go to the soup kitchen and feed people, we go out to the ends of the earth to bring health care and build shelter and serve. But never forget, that wherever we go, we do not “bring God;” God is already there. God has always been there. Among the weeds. Among the displaced. Among the uprooted, downtrodden and crushed, there is God. If we pay attention, we might see the kingdom of God in our midst.

Monday, July 18, 2011

Oh Yes, God Is In This Place

17 July 2011
Genesis 28:10-19a
Psalm 139:1-12, 23-24

When I was a child, I was under the impression that the characters mentioned in Bible stories were all good. Except for the ones who were obviously all bad, of course. Goliath was bad, David was good. Delilah was bad, Samson was good. There were heroes who were all good, and villains who were all bad. And the lesson was, be good. Obey your parents, stand up to bullies, be good as all God’s heroes are good.
So when I started to read the actual bible, not the children’s story bible, I was surprised to see what scoundrels my former heroes could be. Take the story of Isaac’s family. This family is worthy of its own reality show on MTV. Isaac seems to be in his own world, completely unaware or unconcerned with the relationship of people around him. Isaac and his oldest son Esau are tightly bound, share a love of blood sport and red meat. Manly  men. Isaac’s wife Rebecca and their younger son Jacob have a bond that seems to be built on their mutual jealousy of the relationship that Isaac and Esau have with each other. Rebecca devises a plan and Jacob carries it out, to rob Esau of his father’s blessing.
When our story begins, it is the end of the day that Jacob ran for his life. His mother invented an excuse for his departure, to give him time to get as far away from his justifiably angry brother as possible. After deceiving his father and disinheriting his brother and running away from his home, Jacob lies down for a fitful night of sleep.
And that is when he meets his God.
Which goes against everything I learned in Sunday school, which was that if you are very, very good, you will get to see God one day in heaven. And this is how to be good: Honor your father and mother, don’t lie cheat or steal.
Jacob made a fool out of his father, impersonated his brother, stole his father’s blessing and swindled his brother out of his inheritance. And then he saw God. It just doesn’t make sense. And more than that, it’s not fair.
The lesson is not “Be a jerk and see God.”
But perhaps the lesson is, “If you think you know God, watch out.”
Perhaps the lesson is, “No matter how far you run, God will find you.”
“You hem me in, behind and before…. If I ascend to heaven, you are there; if I make my bed in Sheol, you are there. If I take the wings of the morning and settle at the farthest limits of the sea…” there you are, God.
“Once there was a little bunny who wanted to run away,” begins a story by Margaret Wise Brown. I read it many times to my children.
“So he said to his mother, ‘I am running away.’
 "'If you run away,’ said his mother, ‘I will run after you. For you are my little bunny.’”
And the story goes on. The little bunny shares his plans to become a boat and sail far far away, and the mother bunny responds, If you become a boat, I will become the wind and blow you where I want you to go. The little bunny says, Then I will become a crocus in a hidden garden; and the mother says she will become the gardener, and so on. Finally the little bunny says, in that case, I’ll just stay here and be your little bunny.
“Have a carrot,” says the mother.
I can’t help but think of Psalm 139 as “The Runaway Bunny Psalm.”
No matter how ornery, contrary, and mean we become, God is our mother and our father. God will seek us out.
No matter how far we run from our home, God will be there.
Maybe we don’t notice God’s presence so much when we are at home with God, when we are “being good.” When we are living in Christ, loving our neighbor, God’s presence so permeates our lives that God is as the air we breathe. Essentially present, mostly, unnoticed.
It is when we become lost to ourselves that we find God’s presence so surprising. When we find ourselves as strangers in a strange land, a land of grief, a land of need and uncertainty, that we find God’s presence so surprising.
Remember when Joey and Sue came back from Haiti, after the earthquake, and we were so surprised to see all the smiling faces, all the happiness and joy in the midst of such devastation? Surely God is in this place, and I did not know it.
Remember the last time you lost someone you loved, and you wandered in the land of grief and misery, and then, one day, you woke up and realized you were going to live? Surely God is in this place, and I did not know it.
Remember the last time you were truly lost on unmapped roads, roads your GPS didn’t recognize and Rand McNally never heard of, and then you found a landmark, and suddenly knew where you were? Surely God is in this place, and I did not know it.
No matter how far we run, no matter how lost we become, no matter how low or high we go… Surely God is in this place, whether we know it or not. Thanks be to God. Amen.

Monday, June 20, 2011

A Church that Celebrates and Honors All Creation

19 June 2011
Genesis 1, Psalm 8

        How beautiful is the literature of the Old Testament. The scriptures appointed for today demonstrate a balance and parallelism worthy of study by any aspiring writers, poets, or lyricists.
        Take, for example, this first account of creation: in six acts, the first three parallel to the second three:

          1.   Light                                   4. Sun, moon and stars
          2.   Sea and Sky                         5. Birds and fish
          3.    Earth, and plants                   6. Animals, and everything
                                                               that creeps and crawls
                                                                and walks and stalks
                                                                 upon the earth.


And people. It is fascinating coincidence to me that the first chapter of Genesis agrees with the modern scientific account in this respect: we are the latecomers. The second chapter’s creation story is different, but we’re not going there today.  Let’s just remember that there is no conflict between science and religion, there never has been, really, until the early twentieth century when a small minority decided to take offense at Darwin. For most of Christian history, and for most Christians, both science and religion are approaches to understanding the universe.  They ask different kinds of questions, and yet, often come to similar conclusions.
The choral response to each act of the creation story is , “it was good.” Before there was a concept of original sin, there was original blessing. Original blessing takes canonical precedence.
In Friday book group we are reading a book called Saving Paradise which talks about how Christians, for the first thousand years held that paradise was not some distant heaven above, that paradise was here on earth. It is this understanding that we lost, somewhere along the line.  We lost, and the earth lost as a consequence. Hold that thought while we consider the psalm.
Psalm 8 is also a beautifully crafted piece of literature, built upon the framework of the first creation story. It’s a riff on the creation story. A riff, as I understand in musical terms is a musician’s take on a particular melody. Think jazz. Think of how the musicians take the solo in turns: the bassist, the keyboards, the saxophone, even the drums. Each has his or her own take on the melody. This psalm is somebody’s riff on the creation story. It moves in along in a similar groove, from the heavens, downward to the individual, and embellishes the personal implications of the general story.
        What does it mean to be a little lower than God? What does it mean to be given dominion? The question remains unanswered, it echoes down through the ages and invites us to consider for ourselves, our place in the universe. What are the moral implications of dominion?
        Some people seem to think that dominion is like being given the keys to mom and dad’s house, when they go away for the weekend, so they can have a party. They invite all their friends over, and then they trash the place! They can do whatever they want, right? Except, they seem to forget that mom and dad are coming home, eventually. And mom and dad are not going to be OK with this.
       Actually, that metaphor can work, if we remember that mom and dad gave us the keys, because they trust us. They trust us to feed the fish, and look after the lawn. So if we find that our friends are digging up the lawn looking for treasure, if we find that our friends our mucking up the koi pond and killing the fish, it is our responsibility, as trusted caretakers, to do something about it.
        Who are we as a church, to challenge Monsanto? Who are we to go after Big Oil, or Coal? We are the church, that’s who we are. We are a church that celebrates, and honors, all creation. We are a people called to care for creation.
         Let us not forget that this is the paradise that God has created, and declared good; and to this paradise, to the fish and the birds and the beasts and all cattle, God has given us, for caretakers. So let us contemplate together, our identity as a church that celebrates paradise, and honors and protects all God’s creation. Amen.

I would like to acknowledge Rev. Linda Jaramillo, Executive Minister for Justice and Witness Ministries of the United Church of Christ, for providing inspiration for this sermon, in her address to the Minnesota Conference Annual Meeting last weekend. Thank you.

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Christ and Culture, Revisited: H. Richard Niebuhr Shapes the Church

29 May 2011
                Last week, I promised a series on church identity. We will be contemplating our collective identity, who we are as a church, a congregation of a particular tradition in this particular place and time. Our state legislature’s decision, to have a state-wide discussion on the meaning of marriage, brings a religious war to our state. Those who want us to pass a constitutional amendment to define marriage claim that they have God on their side. We will be challenged to defend our identity as Christians, as people of faith.
                I think it will be helpful for us to revisit H Richard Niebuhr’s 1951 work, Christ and Culture, in which Niebuhr describes five distinct ways churches view the relationship between their God and the world in which they live.
                1. Christ Against Culture
                2. Christ Of Culture
                3. Christ Above Culture
                4. Christ and Culture In Paradox
                5. Christ Transforming Culture
The first is to see the arch of history as a sure steady march toward the kingdom of God. This is one of the “Christendom” models. One example of Christ  against Culture might be the dogged determination of late 19th century Americans to conquer and Christianize the west. Ignoring the genocide of the first nations, they saw only good in the spread of military outposts, white settlement, railroads, and protestant missions in the west. It was believed to be the nation’s “manifest destiny,” as inevitable as the march of time.
The second way of viewing the relationship between Christ and Culture, the Christ of Culture, is very like the first. If the Church with a big C can do no wrong, then as long as the Government (big G) is Christian, it can also do no wrong. Christ and Culture are one; or, Christ and the agents that govern and order culture are one. I believe the so-called “Christian Identity” movement belongs to this model. (King James I of England, among other monarchs, was devoted to this model of seeing the world. That’s why our people had to leave!)
Christ above Culture (the third way) is pretty much the straight Lutheran “two kingdoms” way of seeing the world. It is a dualism: this world is a fallen world, marred by sin, prone to wickedness, and the Christian is called to live in the fallen world but not to be of the world. The church and her people must obey the worldly authorities, even if they are wrong; and trust in God to receive the church into the perfected kingdom of God when this world has passed away. Unfortunately, this makes a false idol out of obedience, and renders the church impotent against injustice. If you have ever wondered why so many good Germans did nothing to stop Hitler, consider the power of believing that obedience to earthly authority is required by God.
Christ and Culture in paradox describes the way many minority sects see their place in the world, including those who were disappointed last weekend when they were not taken up in the rapture. This is a model of belief common to Mormons, Jehovah’s Witnesses, and other minority religionists: They believe that they alone are God’s chosen, they alone are pure, they alone will be saved.  Their lot in life is to endure this world while Christ and Satan battle it out, to preserve themselves and as many as they can reach (which is why they feel no regret in knocking on your door and interrupting your dinner—they are doing this to save you), to remain pure, and to persevere in the faith.
Saving the best for last (what author would lead with the climax?), Niebuhr describes another way, seeing the role of Christ, and therefore the church, as the transformer of culture. The world is created by God and it is good, but incomplete, and through Christ and the church God is transforming this world from one glory to the next. Culture is not something to be for or against, culture can be a means for positive transformation, or stasis, or regression.
 Niebuhr is one of ours, by the way. A United Church of Christ theologian, who was raised in the German Evangelical antecedent church; who, like me, was a graduate of Elmhurst College and Eden Seminary.
Seeing Christ as the transformer of culture invites the church to be the same. Just as Jesus challenged the way the Pharisees and the Romans saw the world, we are invited into a critical analysis of our ways of seeing the world. And just as Jesus stood against domination, we are invited to challenge the dominant belief systems that oppress some and elevate others falsely.
God is great, and we are not. God is God, and we are not. Throughout the ages, people have tried their best to understand God, but our understanding is limited by our relatively short span of life and our relatively tiny brains. But over the vast expanse of time we have learned, as a people, we have grown in understanding. God is at work through wisdom, through understanding.
The more we know about the world, the more we learn about each other, the more we learn about God.
H. Richard Niebuhr, 1894-1962, helped to shape the church that we have become, and helped us to see who we are in relation to others, to our predecessors in the faith and to those with whom we share our journey now. He helps us to give voice to our identity as a transformed and transformative church.
As we prepare for our statewide discussion on marriage (a statewide discussion on God, the universe and everything), I hope Niebuhr’s Christ and Culture will help us understand where others are coming from, when they talk about their understanding of God. And I hope this provides all of us with the courage to be who we are as a church, and to stand up for what we believe to be true and just. There is much transformative work to be done.
                Thanks be to God, who is still speaking, still transforming the world with love and justice. Let us join in this transformational work.